9 Best Matte Eyeshadows For Older Eyes

1. Best With Organic Ingredients:Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Cream Matte Natural Eyeshadow – Plum Fairy

  This is the best cream eyeshadow for mature eyes. This gorgeous shade, Plum Fairy, has a cool undertone that accentuates the eyes and suits almost all skin tones. Its natural and organic formula is highly pigmented, blends easily, and offers a rich color payoff. The nourishing ingredients like shea butter, rosehip oil, jojoba oil, and vitamin E moisturize the eyelids. This eyeshadow is suitable for all skin types. Pros

Creamy texture Matte finish Blends easily Rich color payoff Certified organic ingredients Organic vanilla scent Cruelty-free Gluten-free GMO-free Paraben-free

Cons

Pigments fade very quickly

2. Best For A Rich Color Payoff:L.A. Colors Matte Eyeshadow Palette – Purple Cashmere

Your search for dramatic eyeshadows ends with this beautiful matte palette from L.A. Colors. Each palette comes with five blendable shades from the same color family, that can be mixed and matched to create an exciting look. These shades are highly pigmented, offer a rich color payoff, come with a silky texture, and look soft and pretty. The palette Purple Cashmere has five shades from the purple family in cool to warm undertones. You can use these shades to create any look, from neutral to bold. Pros

Silky texture Rich color payoff Buildable colors Matte finish

Cons

Colors oxidize on application

3. Best Long-Wearing:L’Oreal Paris Colour Riche Monos Eyeshadow – #300 Matte Chill

The Colour Riche Monos Eyeshadow in the shade Matte Chill from L’Oreal Paris has a velvety texture and a rich matte finish. Its highly pigmented formula provides intense color payoff. This eyeshadow features cutting-edge Gel to Powder Technology that helps the pigments to blend easily and glide smoothly over the skin. Moreover, its lightweight formula stays comfortable and lasts all day long. Check out the review of this product on YouTube to know why it is one of the best out there. Pros

Intense matte finish Rich color payoff Comfortable wear Long-staying Blends easily Lightweight

Cons

Too much fallout

4. Best Waterproof:Revlon ColorStay Crème Eye Shadow – #705 Crème Brulee

  The Revlon ColorStay Creme Eye Shadow is one of the best-selling powder eye shadows of the brand. It has a smooth and blendable formula that provides a rich and creamy finish on application. This shimmery champagne shade, Crème Brulee,is highly pigmented and stays intact for up to 24 long hours without fading or smudging. Its waterproof formula is suitable for mature eyes, and it comes with a pro-inspired built-in brush for easy application. Pros

Long-staying Creamy texture Buildable shimmery finish Rich pigments Waterproof Comes with an application brush Mess-free application Blendable

Cons

Shimmer particles have a gritty texture

5. Best Blendable:Laura Geller New York Blend Away Eyeshadow Palette

The Laura Geller New York Blend Away Eyeshadow Palette features a lovely selection of rich colors in matte and sparkling textures for creating smoky eyes, natural looks, and so much more. Pick matte eyeshadow or shimmering glitter makeup to make your eyes pop! These silky smooth eyeshadows have a deep color intensity and blend wonderfully on your lids. The combination of berry and floral-inspired colors allows you to create nude and rosy pink eyeshadow looks. These pressed eyeshadows compliment all eye colors and skin tones. Pros

Creamy texture Crease-proof Long-wearing Lightweight Highly pigmented Easy application Cruelty-free Smooth application Affordable

Cons None

6. Best Matte Finish:Demúre Mineral Eye Color –Dusty Rose

  Demure’s Mineral Eye Shadow in the shade Dusty Rose is a gorgeous matte champagne color that suits all skin tones. This powder eyeshadow is water-resistant and infused with minerals that do not irritate the sensitive skin around the eyes. Its lightweight formula is richly pigmented and offers high color payoff to create any desired look. Pros

Matte finish Lightweight Multipurpose Waterproof Filler-free Unscented Irritant-free Preservative-free Cruelty-free Paraben-free Talc-free Rice-free

Cons

Pigments do not blend easily

7. Best Lightweight:Stila Suede Shade Matte Liquid Eye Shadow – Midnight Espresso

  The Suede Shade Matte Liquid Eye Shadow from Stila has a velvety matte yet creamy formula that can be used to create neutral as well as bold looks. The shade Midnight Espresso is a delightful mauvy nude that adds an extra dimension to your eyes. Its color-intense formula works without an eyeshadow primer and can be paired with glitter and shimmer shadows. Its lightweight and extended stay formula glide on smoothly to offer a flawless finish. Pros

Lightweight Creamy texture Smooth application Buildable Rich color payoff Works without primer/base

Cons

Runny consistency

8. Best Cruelty-Free:BYS 12 Shade Matte Eyeshadow Palette

  The BYS 12 Shade Matte Eyeshadow Palette comes packed with12 bold shades to let you create any look you want. Its blendable formula defines and illuminates the eyes while offering a lasting staying power. The palette comes with a wide mirror and a double-ended applicator to get the perfect look without much effort. Pros

Long-staying Blendable Comes with a mirror Includes an applicator brush Matte finish Cruelty-free

Cons

Heavy fallout

9. Best Oil-Free:Mommy Makeup Any Wear Creme – Anna

  The Mommy Makeup Smudge-proof Eye Shadow has a 3-in-1 formula that works as an eyeshadow, cheek color, and lip color. This multitasking creme-to-powder eyeshadow has a waterproof and smudge-proof formula to offer extended stay without any need for touch-ups. It is formulated with vitamins E and A and glides smoothly to provide a seamless finish. The shade, Anna, is a matte rosy beige in warm tones and is one of the best-selling eyeshadows from the brand. Pros

Multipurpose Waterproof Smudge-proof Long-staying Oil-free Conditions the skin Oil-free No creasing Cream-to-powder finish Paraben-free Cruelty-free

Cons

A bit drying

Why Trust Stylecraze?

Baishali Bhattacharya, the author, has a certification in makeup artistry with a zeal for staying on top of chic trends. As you grow older, your skin becomes vulnerable to fine lines and wrinkles, especially around the eyes. One of the best ways to smoothen out those signs of aging and look more youthful is using matte eyeshadows. After spending many hours scouring through the internet and investigating many products and their reviews, she settled with this list. Each of these eyeshadows offers good color payoff, high blendability, and lasts long. Is matte eyeshadow better for mature eyes? Yes. Opt for hydrating matte eyeshadows like the iT Cosmetics Naturally Pretty Eyeshadow Palette, as they are long-wearing and are less likely to fade on mature skin. These eyeshadows will not settle in the fine lines, and some formulas can even prevent the appearance of fine lines. What color of eyeshadow is the best for people over 60? Bright blues and purple shadows may look overdone on matured skin. Natural tones, warmer browns, and grey shades will make your eyes look flattering. What color eyeshadow makes you look younger? Pink and neutral tones of eyeshadows can make you look younger. Neutrals complement your everyday look and don’t look too bold. What color eyeshadow makes eyes look bigger in mature women? You can try neutral shades or medium-tone shades on your eyelids. To make your eyes look bigger, apply the eyeshadow slightly above the crease if you have hooded eyes.

Best Pigmented Eyeshadows With Buying Guide Best Neon Eyeshadow Palettes